Redefining Citizenship

By my husband, also in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer

Guest Columnist: Redefining citizenship


Take a new, liberal president and Congress. Add an economic crisis, assorted international woes and a general lack of confidence. Next, dust off the usual-suspect proposals to reinstate the draft, institute mandatory national service, or just give people opportunities to volunteer. Now lard it well with calls for sacrifice, service and unity in hard times.

Then note that nobody’s listening. America’s Crisis of Citizenship goes on.

When President Barack Obama began his inaugural address by calling us his fellow citizens, he used a word that seems to have little meaning anymore. How could it? The issues before us are too big, too many, too complex. We’re all too selfish, too self-obsessed. Everybody says it. Everybody says it because everybody says it. The surveys, the academics, the pundits say it, too.

But we’re not. At least, we needn’t be. However, to restore citizenship to its vital and honorable place, we need to redefine it. Forget “sacrifice.” Whenever you hear someone demanding sacrifice, somebody else is probably collecting sacrifices. Forget “unity,” that code word for “Do it my way.” Above all else, forget “service.” Citizens don’t serve. They participate.

But what exactly is a citizen these days?

Obviously, citizenship is a legal status. Beyond that, a citizen is a responsible member of this civilization. A responsible member of this civilization adheres to three general guiding principles.

In the political realm, the recovery of respectful reason. We have much to argue over. But ranting and hissy-fitting do not avail. Time for us all to adopt a simple principle regarding our political views. If you can’t explain it, rationally and respectfully, best you rethink it. Whether it’s the narcissistic antics of a Code Pink or the sneering-off of climate change because you don’t like Al Gore, or some bilious blog or TV yakathon, it’s the same mentality: a mentality we never should have indulged and can no longer afford.

Politically, citizens are serious.

Economically, citizens live by a simple axiom. To borrow from Lincoln: As I would not be exploited, so I would not be an exploiter. This leads inevitably to the realization that “cheap” is something we can no longer afford. Cheap food that wrecks the environment and destroys local agriculture. Cheap imported products made by underpaid workers. Cheap immigrant labor here.

Our economic crisis is also a moral crisis. It is immoral to live as we have, gluttoning (on credit) the products of exploited others while wrecking our own capacity to produce and blighting the lives of millions of our fellow citizens. We cannot gimmick our way out of it or return to our former ways.

Culturally, citizenship begins with a simple realization: They want you stupid. The “Dumbing Down of America” is a producer-driven phenomenon. In America, everything gets reduced to entertainment and, more and more, entertainment gets reduced to porn: the pornographies of sex and violence, the pornographies of stupidity and disrespect. The corporate producers of our culture prefer it that way. So do our media and our educational bureaucracies. The sterile, the banal, the formulaic are always easier to produce than the challenging, the original, the meaningful.

Try this. The next time you encounter some particularly hideous commercial or tabloid or whatever, don’t dismiss it. Just tell yourself, “This is what they think of me. This is what they think I want. This is what they think I am.”

Cultural citizenship begins when you realize that, just as your body can’t subsist forever on junk, neither can your mind or your spirit.

So there is indeed a Crisis of Citizenship in this country. But it’s not about sacrifice or unity or service. It’s about a nation that, for far too long, has gorged on political, material and cultural garbage. And perhaps it’s not too much to suggest that the recovery of citizenship begins when enough of us decide:

We’re better than that.

Philip Gold is a local writer. His blog, “The Things You Do, America,” is at

2 thoughts on “Redefining Citizenship”

  1. Excellent! Erin, you do not have an “Al Bundy” for a husband, as some have inferred.
    Believe it or not, I get hate mail for posting on your blog. I have a different take on things from him but we both end up in the same place. Please give him my email if he wants to talk about things.

    God bless you, and yours.

  2. Patrick:

    Philip here. No, I am not an Al Bundy. I’m a grouchy old Marine and one of the few men on earth who can handle Erin. However, I add that the guy who played Al Bundy (name now forgotten) was a very good football player who got cut from the Steelers and then got into acting.

    Glad you liked the article.



    I would believe you get hate mail for posting on my blog. I am not someone who is easily figured out because I don’t fit the standard categories—left, right, center. One reason I do not post on your blog is that I frankly don’t wish to expose you to more hate mail than you get, the more so that I am respectfully surprised that you incorporated a hard link to my blog from yours.

    Of course, if you want me to, I can 🙂

    The more so because the insistence upon pigeonholing people and ideas is absolutely killing this country and endangering the planet (think nuclear power and global warming—you’d think the environmental movement would be absolutely crusading for nuclear power). The Right is, forgive me, utterly toxic. They want the President to fail. The Left is no longer vicious like it was, but it is utterly brain dead. And both sides are, as another correspondent told me, utterly afraid of information contamination. Afraid to think unapproved thoughts, afraid of solutions that might obviate the need for causes—causes that incidentally pay the bills of many of them. And let’s face it, thinking is hard. Acting on your convictions is hard.

    For whatever reason, you are not afraid of that contamination.

    I am about to post an essay that I think you might like—an interviewee has until noon tomorrow to contact me with corrections—and if you’re up for really pissing people off while baffling them with sweet reason, feel free to cross-post it. (Just link back to me.) I’ll shoot a copy your way.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s